Indignant over Assam, well-heeled Indians won’t see the bigger picture

12th August 2012 12:09 AM

As Assam burns, some are busy scoring personal brownie points. When the Assamese are fighting a bloody battle to protect their unique Indian identity, our politicians, their fellow travelers and our globalised chatterati are mourning and lobbying for the rights of the illegal infiltrators. For nationalist Indians, the Assam violence is a pure fight between desis and videshis. It is not a confrontation between religious communities. For centuries, the Northeast, including Assam, was a living example of unity in diversity until armed migrants from across the border cleaved them apart. They have not only divided the Assamese along caste and communal lines, they now define and dictate the contours and colours of the state government.

Last week, our leaders didn’t discuss ways to tame the well-armed illegal infiltrators and deport them. Guided and goaded by the advantages of votebank politics, they are discussing how to polarise votes or find ways to legitimise the illegitimate occupants of Indian land. The fight for the rights of Indians vis-à-vis foreigners has spread to almost every aspect of Indian life, from the social sector to the business world. A coalition of suave wealthy westernised classes is determined to fight for the entry of foreign entities in every walk of Indian life. Why do we adore and promote everything and every entity with a foreign tag? Be it a mall, a residential complex, an automobile brand or even kitchenware, Indians support foreign brands and push out national names and symbols. Is it something to do with the young, new age Indians born with a silver spoon, educated abroad and who have privileged access to both the job market and politics? Defending Vodafone and Bangladeshis are part of their conviction. For them Ram, Rahim or Guru Nanak are mere symbols of faith while the Western economic and social model is their real religion.

The discourse on the Assam tragedy reflects the growing tendency to defend the foreign invasion of Indian land, business, and the cultural and educational system. Except from some vote-chasing politicians, we hardly hear voices or chest-beating on behalf of the Indian poor for whom two meals a day is still a mirage. No elitist, glamorous NGO is seen squatting on dharna or on fast demanding food, shelter and healthcare for the deprived and the underprivileged. But they are hyper-active when there is a strong movement against illegal immigration in India. They condone the defiance of even judicial verdicts. It is fashionable, desirable and rewardable to be politically correct in India than speaking for what is right for India. Some trot out ridiculous arguments to justify the existence of the foreign hand in Indian society and economy—“Aren’t illegal Indian immigrants settled in various parts of the world? Shouldn’t they also be thrown out the way ‘nationalists’ are demanding Bangladeshis and Pakistanis be deported?” They conveniently forget that Indian immigrants are productive assets for any country they live in. They aren’t liabilities. They follow local customs and local laws. They don’t defy them even if they did back home in India. Indians create wealth and jobs for locals and do not displace them. Indians don’t carry arms and manufacture bombs like illegal immigrants are suspected of doing in India. Indians don’t demand separate laws. It is because of Indian companies that over 2,50,000 additional jobs have been created in the US alone.

But foreigners who come to India, legally or illegally, demand preferential treatment in all walks of life. MNCs want tax concessions, immunity from Indian laws and stay without proper documents. For the past few weeks, policy-makers are only talking about reviewing and reversing the Indian tax regime only to attract more foreign direct investment. They are burning the midnight oil to find ways and means to ensure that Vodafone and others aren’t seen as victims of Indian laws. Megaphones of the corporate world are making noises about the environment being negative for growth. None of them are concerned about the rising number of suicides by farmers or the plummeting purchasing power of the marginalised classes. Sadly, it doesn’t bother any well-spoken Indian that of 10,000 Pakistanis who have entered Nagpur with proper visas in the past decade, over 7,000 have vanished without a trace. The local police forgot to track them and pack them home. It doesn’t bother them if the demographic complexion of nearly half a district changes, not because of  indigenous biological reasons but because of illegal immigration from Bangladesh. Unfortunately, it hardly matters to them that MNCs spend millions to influence and manipulate the stock markets to make instant piles of dosh even if the poor investor loses his hard-earned money. They want the journey from home to office on a hassle-free expressway, an ATM next to their apartment, a super mall only a few steps away, and a car and a home loan at concessional rates of interest. If home-grown companies can provide these facilities, they are welcome. If they can’t, let the modern East India Companies walk in and take over our life and system once again. The discourse on Assam carnage, therefore, is part of a sinister attempt to de-Indianise the Indian mindset.

prabhuchawla@newindianexpress.com

Follow him on Twitter @PrabhuChawla

A+ A A-

Comments(30)

One of your best ! A real hard hitting and soul searching expression. The discourse on the Assam tragedy always appears to be shallow, superficial and stereotyped. It is either manipulated or manufactured. This is reflective of a mindset of an almost obsessive and fatal attraction of anything that is foreign.

The very fact my comment was removed proves my contention today the Print and Visual media are in the vice like grip of Church groups of various denominations. They cannot stomach the truth that Church is behind anti- KKNPP, Naxalites, Prevention of Uranium Mining in Meghalaya and all troubles in the NE. If they have the guts to face the truth let them prove it otherwise.

Sir, All this chest beating going on the media in the light of the violence in Assam is strange, to say the least. Arun Shourie in his 'A Secular Agenda' has included in two Appendicies, 'A 1992 report of the Union Home Ministry, warning about the danger to National Security from the unchecked illegal migration into parts of Assam and West Bengal by Bangladeshi Muslims. The second Appendix, is an appeal to the then PM in 1993, from the General Secys. of the Congress in the N.E. States. It appeals to the PM to 'SAVE' the NE from the illegal migration of Bangladeshi Muslim into the NE States.Then there is a 1993 Report to the President of India, from the then Governor of Assam - Gen.Sinha - warning about the danger of an Islamic State coming into existence in Assam, from the illegal migration of Bangladeshi Muslims. Lastly, the Task Force on Border Management, set up by the NDA Govt., reported the springing up of a number of mosques & madrassas on the Indo-B'desh Border. What happened ?

Fantastic Sir!. This is a real out-pouring, straight from the heart of Sri Prabhu Chawla Ji , a master-piece-article that reflects exactly what is going on at present in the minds of many Indians, giving voice to their unspoken feelings. Very rarely we come across a master-piece like this one.. Congrats!

A voice to support the victimised assamese is welcome. CAONGRESS IS SOLD ON vote bank politics. assamese are doomed today , tomarrow the same fate will overtake the complacent lobbies which fight for the destruction of a culture and ultimaely a people. kurup

Sometimes, Chawla gets it wrong. What has Assam got to do with Vodafone? Yes, people want an end to the riots and all illegal immigrants should be thrown out ceremoniously. However, Vodafone IS a victim of Indian laws. How would you like it if the govt asks you to pay 1 lakh tax for each of the articles you wrote in the past? Say, you go to court and win. Then, the govt changes the law itself and makes you liable to pay 1 lakh for each article you wrote since 1962. Like that? And Vodafone bought Hutch's share. Hutch was the beneficiary. Why tax Vodafone for gains it didn't make? And maybe foreign companies can actually do good for India, as it did since 1991 (or I would have been sending you a post card with this mail) and create jobs for farmers whose lands are barren? These are legal foreigners, not illegal immigrants. Don't mix the two. And yes, people are concerned about farmer suicides. Note that farmer suicides happened in those areas where foreign influence was minuscule.

.all voda did is to exploit the loopholes in existing laws....it is more a convention among MNC to create conduit/fake companies in tax haven....owning majority share...they make all deal through these companies....were our esteemed auhtorities not knowing it???

Post a Comment
*
1000 characters left

All comments will be reactively moderated

Disclaimer: The views expressed in comments published on newindianexpress.com are those of the comment writers alone. They do not represent the views or opinions of newindianexpress.com or its staff, nor do they represent the views or opinions of The New Indian Express Group, or any entity of, or affiliated with, The New Indian Express Group. Comments are automatically posted live; however, newindianexpress.com reserves the right to take any or all comments down at any time.

Recent Activity

What's Hot?